6 min read

The Bitcoin Cash chain split: 1 August 2017, block 478,559

Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash were one chain until block 478,558. On 1 August 2017 nodes running the Bitcoin Cash rules began accepting blocks larger than one megabyte, and from the next block on there were two chains with one shared history. This is the record of that split: the dispute, the rule change, the blocks, the names and the balances.

When did the BTC / BCH split happen?

On 1 August 2017. The two chains share every block up to 478,558, timestamped 13:16 UTC that day. The next block, 478,559, exists twice: Bitcoin's was timestamped 13:23 UTC, Bitcoin Cash's 18:12 UTC, mined by ViaBTC and 1.9 MB in size, which the old 1 MB limit did not allow. The split came from a rule change that raised the block-size limit to 8 MB and added replay protection. Every coin held at block 478,558 stayed spendable on both chains, one for one.

The splitBitcoin (BTC)Bitcoin Cash (BCH)
Last shared block478,558, timestamped 1 August 2017 13:16:14 UTC
ActivationBitcoin Cash rules active once the median time of the last 11 blocks reached 12:20 UTC on 1 August 2017
First block after the split478,559, 13:23:00 UTC, 272,502 bytes478,559, 18:12:41 UTC, 1,915,175 bytes, 6,985 transactions, mined by ViaBTC
Rule changeNone: kept the 1 MB limitBlock-size limit 8 MB, first block required to exceed 1 MB, new signature rule (SIGHASH_FORKID)
BalancesEvery coin unspent at block 478,558 spendable on both chains, 1:1
Name and tickerBitcoin, BTCBitcoin Cash, BCH (first listed as BCC)

Why the chain split

Bitcoin had carried a 1 MB limit on block size since 2010. By 2017 blocks were full often enough that fees and waiting times rose, and the network had argued for years over what to do. One side wanted to raise the limit and keep payments on the chain itself. The other preferred to keep the base block small, move signature data out of it with Segregated Witness (SegWit, BIP 141), and carry more payments on second-layer systems. Neither side could bring the other round. The Bitcoin Cash website, as quoted at the time, put it this way: “the community could not reach a consensus, even after years of debate.”

Bitcoin ABC, a node client led by Amaury Séchet, wrote the rules for raising the limit as a hard fork: the user-activated hard fork, or UAHF, specified in July 2017. The mining pool ViaBTC announced support and named the result Bitcoin Cash. SegWit was already on its way to activation on the other side, and it activated on Bitcoin on 24 August 2017, at block 481,824. The two changes could not run on the same chain, so each group of nodes kept its own. The site's two upgrade paths of 2017 covers what each path changed and why the naming that followed is a choice, not a fact about either chain.

The rule change

The UAHF specification (version 1.6, dated 24 July 2017) set four rules that mattered for the split:

The same specification added an emergency difficulty adjustment (EDA): if six blocks took 12 hours or more, the difficulty fell by 20%. Bitcoin Cash began at Bitcoin's difficulty with a small share of the hashpower, and the rule was there so that the chain would not stall. It was replaced on 13 November 2017 by a difficulty algorithm that averages over about 144 blocks.

The blocks: 478,558 and two 478,559s

Block 478,558 is the last block the two chains have in common. Its header is timestamped 13:16:14 UTC on 1 August 2017, and its median time, 12:37:28 UTC, was past the activation point. Seven minutes later Bitcoin had its block 478,559, at 272,502 bytes. Bitcoin Cash's block 478,559 is timestamped 18:12:41 UTC, almost five hours after Bitcoin's. ViaBTC mined it: 1,915,175 bytes and 6,985 transactions, with the coinbase message “Welcome to the world, Shuya Yang!”. The gap follows from the arithmetic: both blocks carry the same difficulty target, and the Bitcoin Cash side had only a small share of the hashpower to meet it.

Header times are set by the miner and can be off by minutes; the block heights and the order are exact. From block 478,559 onward each chain has its own blocks, and a block on one is not a block on the other.

Which side kept which name

The chain that kept the 1 MB limit kept the name Bitcoin and the ticker BTC. The chain that raised it took the name ViaBTC had given it, Bitcoin Cash. ViaBTC's market listed it as BCC before the split, a ticker the BitConnect token already used on many exchanges; BCH became the common ticker for Bitcoin Cash.

Which branch is the original is a label, not a property either chain has. Both start from the genesis block of 3 January 2009 and both carry the same history to block 478,558. One has the name and the larger market; the other kept the path of raising the block-size limit. Hard fork vs chain split covers the mechanism behind that: a rule change without enough agreement leaves two chains.

How balances carried over

Nothing was sent to anyone. Every coin unspent at block 478,558 was in the history of both chains, so whoever held a coin before the split could spend it on either afterwards: one BTC and one BCH for every bitcoin held. Because Bitcoin Cash transactions had to sign with SIGHASH_FORKID, spending on one chain did not spend on the other. That let holders move their coins on each chain separately, without first splitting them by hand.

Coins held on exchanges were credited at the exchanges' own pace. Coinbase first said it would not support Bitcoin Cash, reversed that within days, and on 19 December 2017 opened BCH trading and credited each customer with Bitcoin Cash equal to their bitcoin balance at the time of the split. The site does not count these balances as an airdrop to either side: both chains carry the same coins up to the split, and every coin on either chain was mined, before the split or after it.

Where each chain stands now

Both chains still run SHA-256 proof of work with a ten-minute block target and a 21 million cap, and since 1 August 2017 each has changed its rules on its own.

Bitcoin activated SegWit on 24 August 2017 and Taproot in 2021. Its base block limit is still 1 MB, with witness data counted separately under a block weight limit.

Bitcoin Cash has upgraded on a schedule, usually every 15 May and, until 2020, every 15 November:

Price, market cap, hashrate and rank move every few hours; they are on the Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash asset pages. The site counts both as cryptocurrencies, because each has its own chain and its own consensus: why BTC, BCH and BSV are three cryptocurrencies.

Sources

Related

Seven chain splits, side by side — every split on the price charts, with dates, blocks and names.

The Bitcoin SV chain split — Bitcoin Cash splits again, 15 November 2018.

The eCash chain split — the 8% coinbase rule and BCHA, 15 November 2020.

Bitcoin took two upgrade paths in 2017 — the block-size raise and SegWit, side by side.