6 min read

The Bitcoin SV chain split: 15 November 2018, block 556,767

Fifteen months after splitting from Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash split again. Its two largest node clients shipped different upgrades for the same date, neither would adopt the other's, and the miners behind each spent the next eleven days trying to win on hashpower. This is the record of that split: the two rule sets, the blocks, the names, the balances, and where both chains went afterwards.

When did the BCH / BSV split happen?

On 15 November 2018. The two chains share every block up to 556,766, timestamped 17:52 UTC that day. From block 556,767 they diverge: the Bitcoin ABC chain's block was timestamped 18:02 UTC and the Bitcoin SV chain's 18:16 UTC. Bitcoin ABC's upgrade added canonical transaction ordering and OP_CHECKDATASIG; Bitcoin SV's raised the default block-size limit to 128 MB and restored four original opcodes. The ABC chain kept the name Bitcoin Cash and the ticker BCH. Every coin held at block 556,766 stayed spendable on both chains, one for one.

The splitBitcoin Cash (BCH)Bitcoin SV (BSV)
Last shared block556,766, timestamped 15 November 2018 17:52:01 UTC
ActivationBoth upgrades active once the median time of the last 11 blocks reached 16:40 UTC on 15 November 2018
First block after the split556,767, 18:02:16 UTC, 3,998,758 bytes, mined by the Bitcoin.com pool556,767, 18:16:57 UTC, 13,627,001 bytes
Rule changeCanonical transaction ordering (CTOR), OP_CHECKDATASIG, 100-byte minimum transaction size128 MB default block-size limit, OP_MUL, OP_INVERT, OP_LSHIFT and OP_RSHIFT restored, 500 opcodes per script
BalancesEvery coin unspent at block 556,766 spendable on both chains, 1:1; no replay protection at the split
Name and tickerBitcoin Cash, BCH (BCHABC on some exchanges at first)Bitcoin SV, BSV (BCHSV on some exchanges at first)

Why the chain split

Bitcoin Cash upgraded every six months, and for November 2018 two node clients proposed different upgrades. Bitcoin ABC, the client that had written the 2017 rules, proposed to change how transactions are ordered in a block and to add a new opcode for checking signatures on arbitrary data. Bitcoin SV, a client backed by nChain and by CoinGeek's Calvin Ayre, with Craig Wright as its most prominent figure, rejected both. It proposed instead a much larger default block-size limit, the return of more of the original script opcodes, and a higher limit on opcodes per script, with the stated aim of keeping the protocol close to its original design.

The two sets of rules could not run on one chain, and no compromise was reached before the activation date. Each client activated its own upgrade at the same moment, and miners chose which one to run.

The two rule sets

Both upgrades activated once the median time of the last 11 blocks reached Unix time 1542300000, 16:40 UTC on 15 November 2018. Block 556,766 was the first whose median time passed it, so block 556,767 was the first under the new rules on each side.

Bitcoin ABC (the chain that kept BCH) activated, per the November 2018 upgrade specification:

Bitcoin SV (the chain that became BSV) activated, per its version 0.1.0 release notes:

Neither upgrade changed the signature format, and Bitcoin SV 0.1.0 removed the automatic replay protection feature of Bitcoin Cash clients. An ordinary transaction valid on one chain after the split was valid on the other.

The hash war

Before the split, Craig Wright threatened, as Bitcoin Magazine reported it, a 51% attack on the ABC chain. Once the chains split, both sides kept far more hashpower on their chain than its block rewards paid for, for over a week, each ready to outrun the other. Nothing irregular happened on the ABC chain. Bitcoin ABC released version 0.18.5, announced on 20 November 2018, which treats a block ten deep as final and will not reorganise past it, a protection against deep reorganisations.

On 26 November 2018 CoinGeek announced that “This ends the on-going BCH hash war” and that its chain would go on as Bitcoin SV, ticker BSV. Calvin Ayre said he would let go of the Bitcoin Cash name, and the Bitcoin SV team said it would add replay protection itself.

The blocks: 556,766 and two 556,767s

Block 556,766, the last block the two chains share, was mined by SVPool and timestamped 17:52:01 UTC; it is 2,597,760 bytes. On the Bitcoin Cash chain, block 556,767 was mined by the Bitcoin.com pool and timestamped 18:02:16 UTC, at 3,998,758 bytes and 20,861 transactions. On the Bitcoin SV chain, block 556,767 was timestamped 18:16:57 UTC, at 13,627,001 bytes and 68,705 transactions. From that height on the two chains have different blocks, each built by nodes enforcing one of the two rule sets.

Which side kept which name

The ABC chain kept the name Bitcoin Cash and the ticker BCH. In the first days several exchanges listed both chains under new tickers: Binance and Poloniex as BCHABC and BCHSV, Bitfinex as BAB and BSV. Once the SV side announced its own name, most of the industry settled on Bitcoin Cash, BCH, for the ABC chain and Bitcoin SV, BSV, for the SV chain.

How balances carried over

Every coin unspent at block 556,766 was in the history of both chains, so its holder could spend it on either: one BCH and one BSV for every Bitcoin Cash coin held. Unlike in 2017, there was no replay protection between the chains, so a transaction broadcast on one could be copied to the other. Holders who wanted to move their coins separately had to split them first, for example by spending them together with coins that existed on one chain only.

Exchanges credited balances from a snapshot. Binance credited one BCH ABC and one BCH SV for each BCH held at 16:40 UTC on 15 November 2018; Poloniex and Bitfinex credited both as well. The BSV Association's published upgrade history lists no replay-protection rule among BSV's later upgrades.

Where each chain stands now

Bitcoin SV lost several of its largest listings in April 2019. On 12 April Binance's chief executive wrote that Craig Wright is not Satoshi, after Wright had threatened the pseudonymous Twitter user Hodlonaut with a libel suit for saying so. Binance announced on 15 April that it would delist BSV, with trading ending on 22 April; ShapeShift said it would delist within 48 hours; Kraken closed BSV deposits on 22 April and trading on 29 April.

The chain's protocol upgrades since the split, from the BSV Association's upgrade history:

Craig Wright had long claimed to be Satoshi Nakamoto. In the case brought by the Crypto Open Patent Alliance, Mr Justice Mellor of the High Court of England and Wales announced at the close of the trial on 14 March 2024 that Wright is not the author of the Bitcoin whitepaper, not the person who used the name Satoshi Nakamoto between 2008 and 2011, not the creator of the Bitcoin system and not the author of its first software. The written judgment followed on 20 May 2024.

Bitcoin Cash went on upgrading on its own schedule, from Schnorr signatures in 2019 to CashTokens in 2023 and an adaptive block-size limit in 2024; the list is in the Bitcoin Cash chain split. In November 2020 it split a third time: see the eCash chain split.

Both run SHA-256 proof of work with a ten-minute block target and a 21 million cap. Live price, market cap, hashrate and rank are on the Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV asset pages. The site counts both as cryptocurrencies, because each has its own chain and its own consensus: why BTC, BCH and BSV are three cryptocurrencies.

Sources

Related

Seven chain splits, side by side — every split on the price charts, with dates, blocks and names.

The Bitcoin Cash chain split — the first split, from Bitcoin, 1 August 2017.

The eCash chain split — Bitcoin Cash's third chain, 15 November 2020.

Why BTC, BCH and BSV are three cryptocurrencies — the counting rule applied to the hardest case.