7 min read

The Ethereum Classic chain split: the DAO fork of 20 July 2016

On 20 July 2016 Ethereum changed its own ledger to undo the effects of a single hack. Most miners and nodes went along with it. Enough did not that the unchanged chain kept producing blocks, found a market within days, and has run ever since as Ethereum Classic. The new rule was not a new way of making blocks but a one-time edit to balances.

Why did Ethereum and Ethereum Classic split?

Because Ethereum reversed the effects of The DAO hack. In June 2016 an attacker drained over 3.6 million ETH from The DAO, an investment contract, into a child contract the attacker controlled. At block 1,920,000, mined at 13:20:40 UTC on 20 July 2016, Ethereum's clients applied an irregular state change: they took the ether out of The DAO and its child contracts and put it in a refund contract, WithdrawDAO, where DAO token holders could reclaim 1 ETH for every 100 tokens. Nodes that rejected the change kept the original chain, on which the contracts and the attacker's ether stayed where they were. The changed chain kept the name Ethereum and the ticker ETH; the unchanged chain became Ethereum Classic, ETC. Every balance existed on both chains, 1:1.

Last shared block1,919,999, 20 July 2016, 13:20:38 UTC
First Ethereum block1,920,000, 13:20:40 UTC, extra data dao-hard-fork
First Ethereum Classic block1,920,000, 13:20:39 UTC, a different block at the same height
Rule changeAn irregular state change on Ethereum: the ether of The DAO and its child contracts moved to the WithdrawDAO contract
Balances1:1; every account held the same balance on both chains, except the accounts the fork emptied on Ethereum
Replay protectionNone at the split. Ethereum adopted EIP-155 with chain ID 1 at block 2,675,000 (22 November 2016); Ethereum Classic with chain ID 61 at block 3,000,000 (13 January 2017)
TickersEthereum (ETH) on the changed chain, Ethereum Classic (ETC) on the original

The DAO and the hack

The DAO was a contract on Ethereum that pooled ether from token buyers and was meant to fund projects by their vote. A flaw in its withdrawal code let a caller withdraw again before the contract had recorded the first withdrawal. On 17 June 2016 Vitalik Buterin reported on the Ethereum blog that an attacker was using it to drain The DAO into a child DAO at 0x304a554a310c7e546dfe434669c62820b7d83490. Ethereum.org puts the amount at over 3.6 million ETH. The DAO's own rules held the ether in the child contract for about 27 days, the length of its creation window, which gave the community time to decide what to do before the attacker could move it.

The first answer was a soft fork. Buterin's post of 17 June proposed that clients refuse any transaction that reduced the balance of The DAO or its children, without reversing any block. On 28 June the Geth team published a security alert: the soft-fork code let anyone run contract code up to the block gas limit without paying for gas, a denial-of-service hole that could slow mining and crowd out ordinary transactions. The soft fork was not deployed. By 15 July the client teams had published a different plan, a hard fork.

The rule change: an irregular state change

The DAO fork's new rule applied to one block. It left the way blocks are made and checked as it was and changed the ledger itself, once. EIP-779, which documents it, describes the change: at the start of block 1,920,000, all ether in a fixed list of accounts, The DAO, its extra-balance account and its child DAOs with theirs, is moved to the WithdrawDAO contract at 0xbf4ed7b27f1d666546e30d74d50d173d20bca754. The contract does one thing: a DAO token holder sends tokens and receives 1 ETH per 100 DAO. To keep the two groups of nodes from mixing, blocks 1,920,000 to 1,920,009 had to carry the text dao-hard-fork in their extra-data field, so a node on either side could tell at once which chain a peer followed.

Geth's default followed a coin vote. Jeffrey Wilcke's post of 15 July set the tally for block 1,894,000 on carbonvote, where ETH holders signalled with their balances. Ethereum.org records that over 85% of the votes backed the fork. Some miners refused it on the ground that The DAO's flaw was in a contract, not in the protocol, and that the chain should not be edited to cover it.

The split, block by block

Both chains share every block up to 1,919,999, mined at 13:20:38 UTC on 20 July 2016. The next block on Ethereum, 1,920,000, was mined two seconds later with the refund transfer applied and dao-hard-fork in its header. On the original chain a different block 1,920,000 was mined at 13:20:39 UTC on the same parent, without the transfer. From that moment each group of nodes rejected the other's blocks.

Buterin's announcement that day reported roughly 85% of miners on the fork and about 12 million ETH moved into WithdrawDAO. It also told anyone who wanted to stay on the non-fork chain to run their client with --oppose-dao-fork and to protect themselves against replay. Ethereum Classic's own timeline records the surprise: miners kept supporting the original chain.

Who kept which name

The chain that changed kept the name Ethereum, the ticker ETH and the backing of the Ethereum Foundation, whose clients carried the fork. The chain that did not change took the name Ethereum Classic and the ticker ETC. The minority defended the unedited ledger; the name went with the majority.

The market came quickly. Ethereum Classic's timeline dates the Poloniex listing to 23 July 2016. Cointelegraph reported on 24 July that the mining operator Chandler Guo answered the listing by announcing a 51% attack on ETC with 98 GH/s of hashrate, about three times ETC's at the time, and that ETC's hashrate doubled within hours, putting the attack out of reach. By 26 July, by Cointelegraph's count, ETC traded 82,015 BTC on Poloniex that day against 57,748 BTC for ETH, and Kraken had announced support. On 13 August 2016 Ethereum Classic's supporters published a declaration of independence from the forked chain.

How balances carried over

Every account that held ether at block 1,919,999 held the same amount on both chains afterwards. The only difference was the list of accounts the fork emptied on Ethereum: on Ethereum Classic, The DAO and its child DAOs kept their ether, including the attacker's. Because both chains also inherited Ethereum's 2014 genesis, they share the same original sale allocation.

Neither chain had replay protection. A transaction signed for one was valid on the other, so someone sending ETH could send the same amount of ETC without meaning to, and anyone could rebroadcast it. The fix came separately on each side. EIP-155 adds a chain identifier to every signature, so a transaction is valid on one chain only. Ethereum activated it as part of Spurious Dragon at block 2,675,000 on 22 November 2016, with chain ID 1. Ethereum Classic activated it in the Die Hard upgrade at block 3,000,000 on 13 January 2017, with chain ID 61.

Where each chain stands

Ethereum Classic has kept proof of work and the principle its community calls "code is law": the code of a contract is the final authority over its outcome. It has diverged from Ethereum since. The Gotham upgrade at block 5,000,000 on 11 December 2017 set a fixed issuance schedule under ECIP-1017, cutting the block reward by 20% every 5,000,000 blocks, which caps supply at no more than 210.7 million ETC. The fifth cut came at block 25,000,000 on 22 July 2026, when the reward fell from 2.048 to 1.6384 ETC. The Thanos upgrade at block 11,700,000 on 28 November 2020 doubled Ethash's epoch length under ECIP-1099 to slow the growth of its dataset and keep 4 GB graphics cards mining; the result is the algorithm the site lists as Etchash. Its most recent upgrade, Spiral, activated at block 19,250,000 on 5 February 2024.

Proof of work has also cost it. Its timeline records successful 51% attacks, chain reorganisations by a miner with more hashrate than the rest of the network, in January 2019 and again in August 2020. The upgrade list in ECIP-1066 shows the response, a guard against deep reorganisations known as MESS, switched on by default at block 11,380,000 and off again at Spiral.

Ethereum went the other way. It replaced proof of work with proof of stake at the Merge on 15 September 2022, and a second group of miners split off to keep mining the old way: the EthereumPoW chain split. Ethereum Classic's timeline describes the Merge as cementing its place as the largest proof-of-work EVM network. The site counts both Ethereum and Ethereum Classic as cryptocurrencies: each has its own blockchain and its own consensus, Gasper for Ethereum and Etchash for Ethereum Classic. Their live price, market capitalisation, rank and hashrate are on their asset pages.

Sources

Related

Seven chain splits, side by side — every split on the price charts, with dates, blocks and names.

The EthereumPoW chain split — the second time Ethereum's miners kept an old chain, at the Merge.

Hard fork vs chain split — a rule change, and what happens when not everyone makes it.

The counting rule — why both sides of a split can count as cryptocurrencies.